McGill Policy Association

View Original

How Central Bank Digital Currencies are Shaping the Future of Finance

Image By: New York Times

Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) first emerged during the 2000s  when the bank of Finland launched its own form of digital currency system. Nevertheless, it is only in the last decade that they have taken such a pivotal force in the global financial landscape. Factors such as the pandemic, the rise of crypto currencies or Facebook’s announcement that it could launch digital remittances accelerated this transition. It induced a shift in payment habits towards the use of digital payments and contactless transactions. As a result, central banks have reacted by seeking ways to avoid losing control over their financial systems. They have undertaken significant efforts to expand transformative initiatives and allocate resources towards research and development in the realm of digital currency. This ongoing process has led to a fundamental shift in our understanding of money, finance, and policymaking.

CBDCs represent the digital versions of a nation's fiat currency. They differ from traditional government-issued currencies in their underlying shared database that stores information in blocks linked together via cryptography called blockchain or distributed ledger technology. However, unlike decentralized cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, their value is fixed and regulated by central banks. Over the years, CBDC adoption has evolved from theoretical discussions to tangible actions, with various countries and regions actively experimenting with these digital currencies. At present, 87 countries representing more than 90 per cent of global GDP are exploring CBDCs and many have already implemented them. Notable examples include China's digital yuan, the Bahamas' sand dollar, and Sweden's e-krona, each pursuing distinct objectives.

CBDCs offer an array of potential benefits for both governments and citizens. First and foremost, they have the capacity to significantly enhance payment efficiency and security, thereby mitigating the risks associated with cash transactions. Moreover, CBDCs can foster financial inclusion by providing banking services to unbanked and underbanked populations, reducing economic disparities. Transacting with CBDCs doesn't require a bank account, which is particularly important in developing countries where typically a third of the population lacks access to traditional finance but has access to mobile internet. This means that more countries that are traditionally outside of the banking system will be integrated into the financial system.

From a monetary policy perspective, central banks gain access to new tools and enhanced transparency for monitoring and managing the money supply, offering greater control over economic stability. Additionally, CBDCs hold the potential to combat illicit financial activities through increased traceability and compliance. The cost of fraud to U.S. financial services companies is estimated at 1.5 percent of revenues, or around $15 billion annually. Moreover, CBDCs facilitate instantaneous transactions, which results in money circulating faster, thereby reducing the need for short-term credit and potentially lowering overall debt levels by 25 percent which is estimated to account for $13 trillion. An even bigger impact could result from the lowering of default rates due to the precision of CBDC transaction data in monitoring the use of credit. In addition, with real-time data on CBDC transactions and holdings, central banks can make better informed decisions about interest rates, money supply, and economic stability. This increased transparency can lead to more effective and responsive monetary policy.

Despite their potential advantages, CBDCs also present a set of challenges and concerns that must be addressed. Striking the right balance between privacy and surveillance issues is essential. Blockchain transactions are inherently transparent, meaning that all transactions can be publicly traced and verified. While transparency is crucial for preventing illicit activities, it can potentially infringe upon individuals' privacy. In addition, addressing technological and cybersecurity risks is imperative to safeguard against hacking and fraudulent activities that could undermine trust in CBDCs.

Furthermore, CBDCs can reach unbanked populations who have been excluded from the financial system. This outreach can lead to a reduction in economic disparities and improve financial literacy among marginalized communities. Nevertheless, CBDCs requires thoughtful implementation. Outreach programs, digital literacy campaigns, and user-friendly interfaces are essential to ensure that everyone can access CBDCs effectively. Governments and central banks must work in tandem with financial institutions and technology providers to build the necessary infrastructure for this inclusive transition.

Moreover, the potential disruption of traditional banking systems poses a challenge in maintaining financial stability. It allows individuals and businesses to hold CBDCs without the need for traditional bank accounts. This shift in the financial landscape may reduce the funds available for commercial banks, impacting their lending capacity and profitability. Another concern involves the central bank's role as a wholesale lender of first resort. This may expose state-controlled credit to political pressures for sector-focused lending. Consequently, if the central bank becomes the primary funding source, it might face political pressure to allocate funds in favor of specific economic sectors. In addition, central banks must carefully consider the potential impact of CBDCs on traditional monetary policy tools. For instance, if CBDCs gain widespread adoption, the demand for physical currency may decline, affecting the effectiveness of conventional open-market operations. Central banks will need to adapt their strategies and tools to this changing landscape to ensure continued economic stability. 

On the international stage, the introduction of CBDCs may give rise to conflicts over issues such as sovereignty, currency exchange rates, and international trade dynamics, requiring international coordination. These challenges would derive from distinctions between residents and non-residents, domestic and foreign transactions, and would raise Anti-money laundering (AML) and Combating the Financing of Terrorism (CFT) enforcement concerns. Additionally, CBDCs could alter market dynamics, liquidity provision, and may lead to capital movements, affecting exchange rates. Therefore, during times of risk aversion, CBDCs can facilitate quicker deleveraging in capital markets, impacting funding conditions and foreign exchange rates therefore necessitating international cooperation. 

To address this challenge, effective policy making is critical. This entails establishing robust regulatory frameworks and legal infrastructures to govern CBDC issuance, circulation, and usage. As ensuring the security and resilience of CBDC networks is crucial to maintaining trust in the financial system. CBDC designs should improve by integrating robust privacy features, such as cryptographic techniques like zero-knowledge proofs that enable private transactions while ensuring the validity and integrity of the ledger. Regular audits and security assessments should be conducted to identify and address vulnerabilities. Moreover, the success of CBDCs may depend on their user-friendliness and ease of adoption for the general public. Central banks must assess meticulously the implications of CBDCs on monetary policy, including their potential impact on interest rates and the money supply. Therefore, striking the right balance between fostering innovation and preserving financial stability is essential as CBDCs evolve. 

CBDCs represent a transformative force in the future of finance. They offer a wide range of potential benefits while also posing significant challenges. To harness the full potential of CBDCs, effective policymaking and careful consideration of privacy, financial inclusion, monetary policy, technological security, and international implications are essential. As nations and regions continue to explore and experiment with CBDCs, cooperation between the public and private sector will be crucial in shaping a financial landscape that is both innovative and stable, ultimately benefiting citizens and economies worldwide.