New York Can’t Build Its Way Out of Rikers

In March 2020, New York City had 5,419 people in its jails, but just six weeks later, it had 3,809, the lowest number it had reported this century and since the 1940s. The city didn’t have to build anything new for this to happen. Instead, it used policies it already had in place, releasing people serving short sentences and those held for parole violations. Now, six years later, the city is legally required to close Rikers Island, and its plan depends on building new jails. But the drop in 2020 shows that what the city needs to do is not build new facilities, but hold fewer people in its jails.

Rikers is New York City’s primary jail complex, situated on an island in the East River between The Bronx and Queens. A majority of the around 6,700 people in city jails have not been convicted of any crime. Instead, they are awaiting resolution of their cases. In 2015, the city settled a lawsuit over excessive force by correction officers and agreed to implement reform. Nearly a decade later, a federal judge found the city in contempt for failing to follow court orders, and appointed an outside remediation manager with power over how the jails are run. The court’s appointed monitor found that use of force and stabbings in the first half of 2025 were higher than in 2016, when the city first agreed to reforms. In 2025 alone, fifteen people died in custody.

In 2019, the City Council voted to close Rikers by August 31, 2027, and replace it with four smaller jails in Brooklyn, The Bronx, Queens, and Manhattan. This deadline is already projected to be missed, with current Mayor Zohran Mamdani saying that meeting it was "practically impossible." These new borough jails are now projected to cost $13.7 billion, much higher than the original estimate of $8.7 billion. As of now, the last borough jail is not expected to open until 2032, five years after the deadline. Even when all four jails are completed, they will hold only 4,160 people, while the current city jails hold about 2,600 more.

Rikers has to close, but building new facilities won’t fix what went wrong there. What the city’s jail system needs to do is jail fewer people for less time. Perhaps building four new jails was not the best way to get there. The city is spending $13.7 billion on buildings while programs that actually reduce the jail population, like mental health treatment and alternatives to incarceration, are facing major funding gaps.

Still, the current plan is already underway. Brooklyn’s jail frame is complete, and construction has started in The Bronx. That makes reforms even more urgent, not less. The new jails can’t even hold today’s population, meaning Rikers cannot close without reform; and the further the population falls, the stronger the case for scaling back the jails that haven’t been built yet.

Much of the current problem is how long people stay. In 2022, stays in New York City jails averaged 114 days, compared with 55 days across the five largest jail systems in the country. At the end of 2023, 1,343 people had been held for more than a year. The same analysis estimates that bringing stays down to levels seen in similar large systems would cut the population by about 46 percent, to roughly 3,300.

Getting below 4,160 and staying there means using tools that already exist. At the city level, the mayor can expand the early release program that worked in 2020, which covers people serving city sentences of a year or less. The city also funds supervised release, which lets judges release people with regular check-ins instead of setting bail. It can fund the mental health beds and supportive housing that the Independent Rikers Commission says the city needs, so people with serious mental illness are treated instead of jailed.

Further reforms can be implemented and controlled at the courts and state level. The commission estimated that faster case processing could cut the jail population by up to 2,000 people. Researchers have proposed specific fixes, such as an automatic bail review for anyone still in jail five days after bail is set, and a hearing for anyone held before trial for 180 days.

The strongest objection is public safety. More people in city jails face serious charges than a decade ago. The portion charged with violent felonies has risen 72 percent since 2016. Critics like Rafael Mangual of the Manhattan Institute have argued that the city can’t shrink its jails to fit the new buildings without releasing people who pose a real danger. This is a serious concern, but none of the reforms that I have described above are about releasing people charged with violent crimes. Instead, it means not holding someone for over a year without a trial, not jailing people for missed parole appointments, and not using a cell as a substitute for psychiatric care. Additionally, someone charged with a violent felony who waits three years is not exactly a public safety success. It’s a failure of the courts, and it hurts victims waiting for resolution.

It is clear Rikers has to close; a federal court has condemned its conditions. But closing it was never supposed to be just about moving people into newer buildings. Building them without reform only moves the problem elsewhere.

What New York needs is a jail system that holds fewer people, for less time, meaning faster courts, bail reviews, early release for short sentences, and treatment instead of jail for people with serious mental illness. None of this requires inventing anything new. The 2020 slashing of the jail population in six weeks resulted from officials choosing to act. Closing Rikers for good depends on making that choice again, so the four new jails don’t end up repeating what went wrong on Rikers.

Edited by Alexander Lesiuk

Next
Next

A new age for the EU: Canadian associate membership and the potential impact on EU international relations